All-Americans
Listed below are the "Backs" who earned All-Americans honors as high school/college players.
| Year: | Name: | Position: | High School: | College | All-American Honor: |
| 2003 | Phillip Britton | C | Olney, IL | Olney Central College | 2004-2005 NJCAA All-American |
| 2004 | Tyler Choate | 1B | Carmi, IL | U.S.I. | 2011 Daktronics Honorable-Mention All-American |
| 2006-07 | Neil Holland | RHP | Owensboro Catholic, KY | University of Louisville | 2010 NCBWA First-Team All-American |
| 2007 | Brad Vance | SS | Holy Cross, KY | U.S.I. | 2012 Pre-Season Collegiate All-American |
| 2007 | Kolbrin Vitek | RHP | Bryan, OH | Ball State University | 2010 First-Team Louisville Slugger All-American |
| 2005-2007 | Stewart Ijames | OF | Owensboro Catholic, KY | University of Louisville | 2008 Louisville Slugger Freshman All-American |
| 2007 | Stephen Shackleford | RHP | Trinity, KY | Savannah College Art& Design | 2010 Second-Team All-American |
| 2008 | Justin Amlung | RHP | St. Xavier, KY | University of Louisville | 2012 Third-Team Louisville Slugger All-American |
| 2008 | Derek Self | RHP | Caverna, KY | University of Louisville | 2009 Louisville Slugger Freshman All-American |
| 2008-10 | Justin Hageman | RHP | Hopkinsville, KY | Western Kentucky University | 2009 Louisville Slugger Freshman All-American |
| 2009 | Sean Godfrey | OF | New Albany, IN | Ball State University | Third-Team College All-American |
| 2010 | Kyle McHugh | 1B | Custer, WI | Wisconsin Stevens-Point | First-Team DIII All-American |
| 2013 | Mark Giesler | 1B | Jasper, IN | Dayton University | 2013 Maxpreps High School All-American |
| 2013 | Dustin Cartas | C | Logan County, KY | Murray State University | 2013 First-Team High School All-American |
| 2014-15 | Tyler Ward | RHP | Heritage Hills, IN | Indiana State University | 2016 Louisville Slugger Freshman All-American |
| 2015 | Jackson Campbell | C | Logan County, KY | Belmont University | 2020 3rd-Team Pre-Season All-American |
| 2014-16 | Easton McGee | RHP | Hopkinsville, KY | University of Kentucky | 2016 Max-Preps Second-Team All-American |
| 2014-2016 | Logan Wyatt | 1B | Bullitt East, KY | University of Louisville | 2018 Collegiate Third-Team All-American |
| 2016 | Jordan Cozart | SS | Ev. Central, IN | Murray State University | 2019-2020 3rd-Team All-American |
| 2016-18 | Ryan Hawks | RHP | Warren East, KY | University of Louisville | 2018 PG Pre-Season First-Team All-American |
| 2016-17 | Wyatt Stevenson | C | Christian County, KY | University of Louisville | 2017 Maxpreps Sophomore All-American |
| 2017 | A.J. Hacker | RHP | Rowan County, KY | Indiana University | 2019 First-Team High School All-American |
| 2017 | Dallas Glass | RHP | Pleasure Ridge Park, KY | Western Kentucky University | 2017 Maxpreps Sophomore All-American |
| 2017 | Luke Brown | OF | Bowling Green, KY | University of Louisville | 2019 NJCAA 2nd-Team All-American |
| 2017 | Tanner Craig | 1B | Austin, IN | University of Evansville | 2021 NCWBA 2nd-Team All-American |
| 2018 | Savier Pinelas | SS | Riverside, WI | Wabash Valley College | 2021 NJCAA 1st-Team All-American |
| 2020 | Grant Knipp | C | Louisville Male, KY | Campbell University | 2020 NHSBCA Pre-Season All-American |
| 2020 | Jonathan Hogart | OF | Madisonville-North, KY | Wabash Valley College | 2021-2022 NJCAA 2nd-Team All-American |
| 2019-2021 | Max Bergmann | RHP | St. Xavier, KY | University of Cincinnati | 2021 NHBCA Pre-Season All-American |
| 2022 | Camden Ross | C | Broomfield, CO | Western Kentucky University | 2022 ABCA 2nd-Team All-American |
| 2024 | Jon LeGrande | OF | George Washington, NY | Wabash Valley College | 2024 3rd-Team NJCAA All-American |
| 2024 | Grant Knipp | C | Louisville Male, KY | Campbell University | 2024 Mid-Season College All-American |
